Cheap Car Insurance Quote Near Me | Compare Car Insurance Quotes in NY

User Review
5/10 (1 vote)

Cheap Car Insurance Quote Near Me NY

Are you looking for the best and cheapest car insurance in New York? Then do not settle for the first car insurance quote that comes to you. Shop around, compare several quotes. You will find that the auto insurance rates varied from company to company in NY.

Compare Best Car Insurance In NY

Below is a summarize comparison of some of the largest car insurers in New York. You can have a good estimate of how much to expect based om what type of drivers you are.

You are a good driver | Our Choice is Travelers

Congratulation. Most of the car insurance companies in NY offer good insurance rate for this type of driver with clean driving record and good credit. Travelers by far offer the best car insurance rate, averaging around $149 per month. Geico is next at $180 per month.

Cheap Car Insurance QuoteYou have poor credit | Our Choice is Geico

If you are a driver with bad credit in New York, then Geico offers the cheapest insurance rate averaging about $288 per month This is followed by Travelers at $310 per month

You had 1 recent at-fault car accident | Our Choice is Travelers

If you had recently had an at-fault accident in New York, then Travelers offers the cheapest auto insurance rate at $150 per month.

You are a low-mileage driver | Our Choice is Travelers

The cheapest car insurance in NY for low mileage drivers is from Travelers, averaging at about $149 per month. Geico and Liberty Mutual followed closely next.

You prefer minimum car insurance coverage | Our Choice is New York Central Mutual.

New York Central Mutual gives the cheapest car insurance quote in New York at $88 per month for those that prefer minimum coverage. This type of coverage is good for those that cannot afford anything more but still need some form of auto accident insurance coverage.
Cheap Car Insurance Quote Near Me | Compare Car Insurance Quotes in NY 1

Alternative Car insurance In NY, New York

If you have a record of several accidents, or DUIs crashes, then car insurance companies in NY may decline your application. In such case, you need to look for alternative car insurance that is willing to provide you with the auto coverage.

Auto Insurance Reviews | Top Car Insurance Companies

21st Century Insurance

They are best known for providing all their auto insurance services from online and phone.


AARP targets older adults and have products and services cater primarily for this age group of people


They are the 3rd largest insurance company in United States with close to 12,000 exclusive agencies representing them in the car insurance service

American Family Insurance

Their insurance products are available across the West and Midwest in total of 19 states.


Amica is one of the more popular insurers among the Americans. They scored high in customers satisfaction.

Erie Insurance

They market their insurance products primarily by word of mouth. They operate in 12 states.

Farm Bureau Insurance

Just like the name suggest, they were founded to serve farmers. They have 1700 agents currently helping to sell policies.

Farmers Insurance

They used to serve only the farmers. But they have since expanded to serve all across the 50 states.


They are the 2nd largest insurer in the nation and is ideal for those that prefer to manage their policy online.

Liberty Mutual

They have good reputatio and strong financial ratings.

Mercury Insurance

They are a big player in California and offers coverage across 11 states.

Nationwide Insurance

This well known insurer is great with customers and rarely have any complaints from their customers.

Progressive Insurance

They are the 4th largest auto insurance company and have features that let you name your own price that fits your budget.

State Farm

Once of the largest auto insurer in the nation and has more than 18,000 insurance agents.

Travelers Insurance

One of the largest and best auto insurance company that offers mid-range prices and great discounts.


They are founded in 1953 and specialized in high risk driver.

Infinity Insurance

They operate in Arizona, California, Texas and Florida and sell new policy to high risk drivers.

Direct Auto Insurance

They provide auto insurance in 13 states across South and lower Midwest.

The General Insurance

They are well known for their free and anonymous quotes.


High end insurance provider and offers generous perks for those that can afford them.


They are great for driver than drive less than 10000 miles per year. Metromile offers 24 hours claim service which can be very useful.


They provide per mile insurance and is great for drivers that do not drive often.


This is one of the cheapest option. USAA serves only active duty military members, veterans and their families.

error: Content is protected !!
Home Privacy Policy Terms Of Use Anti Spam Policy Contact Us Affiliate Disclosure Amazon Affiliate Disclaimer DMCA Earnings Disclaimer